Tarnished Belle

Were it not for my frustration about Phillip being wasted, I would be wholeheartedly cheering Belle’s fall from her pedestal. As it is, it is still very satisfying to see some of the glitter washed off. I would love to believe that the show is finally embracing Belle as an entitled princess bitch who wants it both ways. They are playing Hope’s attitude just right, hope that everything will work out for her son but distrust in the probability. There are some nice layers there, instead of the standard extreme reactions of either “I know your secret and I hate you” or “If you slept with Phillip I’m sure you had an awesomely great reason!”

The show got my hopes up this week on the Phillip front, by giving him some dialogue that brings him a little out of Belle’s devoted creepy puppy dog territory. When Belle went to see him on Wednesday (11/21) because she was upset to learn that Hope told Kayla about The Incident, Phillip wasn’t laying down for anybody:

Belle: Don’t ignore me.
Philip: I’m not ignoring you. I’m busy.
Belle: You told me to call you if I needed you. I called. You told me to come here.
Philip: Not to fix your problems with Shawn’s mother. I’m not your guy friend or your go-to shoulder when things go wrong with the Bradys.


Philip: I can’t change who knows or who Hope tells next. Don’t insult me by calling us friends.
Belle: Well, I wish we could be.
Philip: Sit down. Please. When you called…I thought you were coming over to tell me the wedding was off…that you and Claire were coming home for good. I gave you that number if you needed to talk about us. Marrying Shawn is a huge mistake.
Belle: Well, thanks for the support. I appreciate it.
Philip: Oh, stop acting like a brat.
Belle: What did you just call me?
Philip: You want Shawn and you want me waiting in the wings, like a kid who can’t decide what toy she wants to play with next. I’m not playing safety to Shawn, not even for you. Now, please leave. I’ve got work to do.

Of course the next minute they were making out on the couch, but I’m hopeful that maybe Phillip is starting to wake up to the fact that Belle is no prize. But on the other hand, this could be just that familiar, infuriating soap technique, where they nod to the audience’s frustration by having some character articulate everything we’re thinking. But in the end it makes no difference in the plot.

The other thing that gives me hope for Phillip is that we’re finally seeing him in scenes with other people. Seeing him with Steve and Kayla was a treat and much too brief, but I also loved him with Kate and Lucas last week in the plot shenanigans about Kate’s gun. Phillip the Kiriakis heir came out to play at the police station, when he refused to answer any questions and contemptuously flicked his lawyer’s card on the floor.

There were also the scenes with Max at the Cheating Heart, where he was drowning his sorrows about Belle but also tossing off great one-liners like when Max told him he shouldn’t drive because he’d been drinking too much: “I got a driver outside. He’s paid to wait there. If I came out of here a week from tomorrow, he’d still be there.” There was also the hint that he wants Belle because she already knows about his prosthetic leg, and he doesn’t want to go through explaining it to someone new.

I haven’t watched today’s episode yet, but I predict that Belle will go through with the wedding, because that’s what soap heroines always do. They’ll probably refrain from having Belle flash back to her sex with Phillip during the actual wedding, unlike during everyone other conversation she’s had with Shawn since it happened. But undoubtedly there will be a scene of Phillip smoldering in the background, and at some point Belle will turn and and give him a longing look which no one else will notice.

ETA: Well, I was just joking around, but I was wrong about Belle not flashing back to Phillip sex during the wedding. Color me shocked! And no longing look from Belle, but Phillip did indeed smolder very nicely. One out of three—eh. At least we got a Chick kiss.


5 thoughts on “Tarnished Belle

  1. I have also enjoyed Belle getting some of her glitter knocked off. I have mixed feelings about FancyJudgmentalFace, only because I hate that she’s keeping the secret and invading Belle’s privacy only for the reason of protecting her doofus of a son.

    But, I’m glad that she is kind of calling Belle out on her crap and loved Philip doing it even more. The problem is that they both didn’t go far enough. Hope’s being way too passive/aggressive about it (“I’ll keep your secret and I love you, but I’ll also make it clear I don’t trust you, tell everybody but Shawn, and hold it against you forever”) and Philip’s still chasing after Belle instead of dropping her.

    Nonetheless, the show has given us some hope and has at least given us scenes with Philip and other people which have been fantastic. They’ve also unleashed Philip’s inner Kiriakis which has been awesome. And, while I wish it had gone further, I am glad that they haven’t had everybody defending Belle for having some great reason to sleep with Philip. Now, if the ultimate fallout results in Shawn leaving town, Belle completely alone, and Philip with a woman worthy of him, it will all be great.

  2. I agree with you about FancyJudgmentalFace. At the wedding her constant checking up on Belle was a little too over the top. But it made me laugh every time the camera panned over the guests to see Hope’s dagger eyes. What a way to start your relationship with your mother in law!

    And I’m totally with you on this:

    Now, if the ultimate fallout results in Shawn leaving town, Belle completely alone, and Philip with a woman worthy of him, it will all be great.

  3. I don’t mind Hope’s judgementalness but I’m irritated she didn’t FORCE Belle to tell Shawn. (If you don’t tell him yourself, I’ll do it for you.) And before long the whole town will know before Shawn, leaving it up to Claire to tell her Dad about her Mom sleeping with her other daddy.

  4. Your first sentence says it all: the glitter needed to come off, but I hate that Philip’s the one who had to do it. I said on TWoP that I don’t need for Belle to be painted the town whore, but I do need for both Shawn and Philip to see her for what she really is.

    I just don’t see that Belle loves anyone other than herself. I can’t get invested in her being in any relationship because I just can’t stand the character. At least we did get Philip calling her out, which nobody else ever does. Except for FJF, who, as esp13 correctly points out, is being extremely passive-aggresive and seems to me to be loving holding Belle’s secret over her head. I’m almost starting to feel sorry for Shawn, which I never thought would happen.

  5. Tripp, I hope this doesn’t turn into one of the “the whole town knows” secrets and yet somehow Shawn never finds out. But it certainly seems to be headed in that direction.

    Paxton, I like Belle the character a tiny bit more than you do (though I still want her far, far away from Phillip), but this whole “two mean fighting over her” is just not believable. MM has very little sparkle. She is very intense, though, and could play a bitch, a stalker, or a repressed spinster very well, I think.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s